Religious Accommodation Adds a New Question for Workplace AI

Religious Accommodation Adds a New Question for Workplace AI

A research administrator at the University of Kentucky was granted a religious accommodation after saying AI use would go against his conscience. The employee raised concerns about environmental damage, people’s ability to make a living and human creativity being taken or replaced. For companies adding AI to daily work, the case brings up questions about how far companies can go in requiring employees to use it.

How Religious Accommodations Affect AI at Work

Jay Blanton, speaking for the university, said the university looks at each request separately. In this case, the university found that the employee could still carry out his essential job duties if the university granted the accommodation, Blanton said. An accommodation can also get another review when technology or an employee’s duties change, Blanton said. Approval now does not mean the arrangement will stay the same, and the university could revisit the accommodation later to see whether it still works.

Another case appeared in media reports in June. A software engineer in North Carolina who was Unitarian Universalist received an accommodation after raising concerns about the environmental effects of AI and ethical questions about using the technology.

Employer or stateEmployee roleIssues raisedOutcome
University of Kentuckyresearch administratorEnvironment, people’s livelihoods and creativityAccommodation granted
North Carolinasoftware engineerEnvironment and ethical concernsAccommodation granted

Employment law experts have said employers could see more religious objections as employers start using AI in their businesses. Claims involving religious discrimination have increased since the COVID-19 pandemic, the experts said. And AI brings moral questions as well, which are another issue employers have to consider when deciding how employees will use the technology. For businesses purchasing AI tools, the cases raise a separate question about who will actually use what the business buys. Buying access does not necessarily mean every employee will use AI, and a business might pay for access for its entire staff while employees with accommodations continue doing their jobs in a different way.

Refusing Requests Now Takes a Stronger Case

Employers may turn down religious accommodation requests under laws including Title VII, a provision in 1964’s Civil Rights Act, if employers can demonstrate undue hardship. But a 2023 decision by the U.S. Supreme Court changed how courts weigh that burden. The ruling in Groff v. DeJoy said a substantial burden is needed, measured against the employer’s business as a whole. Legal experts said that raises the bar from the earlier standard, under which a far smaller cost could qualify as undue hardship. Employers also have the option of drawing up policies on AI ethics, which could address:

  • Safeguarding data privacy and dealing with discriminatory decisions.
  • Making sure humans have a role in final decisions by businesses.

Fear of discrimination and anxiety can stop workers from asking about the options available to them, experts said. That can leave employers unaware of workers’ objections even as employers bring AI into more of the work employees do.

The harder question is how long an accommodation can keep working if an employee’s job changes along the way. The university has said an accommodation can be considered again when technology changes or an employee’s duties change, and that leaves open the possibility that employees and managers will need to discuss the arrangement again later.

FAQ

When can employers turn down religious accommodation requests involving AI?

Employers can reject a requested accommodation if they can show undue hardship. Under the ruling from 2023, that burden has to be substantial when considered against the business as a whole.

Who received an accommodation involving AI?

The cases involved a research administrator at the University of Kentucky and a North Carolina-based software engineer who was Unitarian Universalist. The software engineer’s case was reported in June.

Could an accommodation change after approval?

Blanton said the university can look again at accommodations when technology changes or job duties change, and consider whether the arrangement is still reasonable and practical.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest.

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for Subscribing!
We'll be sending you our best soon!
Something went wrong, please try again later